Explain G.E. Moore's argument against scepticism.

G.E. Moore performs something known as the G.E. Moore shift. This is where he takes the sceptic's Modus Ponens argument: (1) If you can doubt the natural world then you cannot know anything about the natural world (P=>Q) (2) You can doubt the natural world (e.g. because of Descartes' Deamon) (P) (c) You cannot know anything about the natural world (Q) And turns it into a Modes Tollens argument (1) If you can doubt the natural world then you cannot know anything about the natural world (P=>Q) (2) You can know things about the natural world (that Moore has two hands) (~Q) (c) You can't doubt the natural world (~P)

GP

Related Philosophy A Level answers

All answers ▸

Outline and Explain Moore's Open Question Argument (9 marks)


Explain the empiricist distinction between simple and complex concepts.


What is the method of doubt?


Explain and illustrate two reasons for holding the view that at birth the mind is a tabula rasa (blank slate). [15 marks]