Explain how one of Gettier’s original counter examples attacks the tripartite view of knowledge.

The tripartite view of (propositional) knowledge (call this view: TVK) is a view that wishes to give an analysis of constructions such as "X knows that p" where 'X' stands for a noun phrase referring to a person and 'p' is a placeholder for a sentence. According to TVK "X knows that p" iff (if and only if): 

X believes that p 

X is justified in believing that p 

That p is true 

(These conditions are all necessary and jointly sufficient) 

Edmund Gettier (1963) proposed the following counterexample to this view: 

Suppose two people A and B are going for a job interview. A has been told by some authoritative individual in the company that B is going to get the job. A has also just seen B count out all of the coins in their pocket, they totalled 10. A believes that: 

(i) B is going to get the job and B has 10 coins in their pocket

A infers from (i) to (ii): 

(ii) The person who is going to get the job has 10 coins in their pocket

Suppose, however that A will in fact get the job. And, not only that, A happens to have 10 coins in their pocket. (ii) is therefore true, A believes (ii), and A is justified in believing it because they inferred it from premises that were themselves justified. However, intuitively we wouldn't want to say that A knows (ii). So we have a case where A has a justified true belief that (ii) but A does not know that (ii). 

Answered by Tutor55396 D. Philosophy tutor

4905 Views

See similar Philosophy GCSE tutors

Related Philosophy GCSE answers

All answers ▸

Explain Descartes' argument for the indivisibility of the mind. [5 marks]


What does it mean to say that a philosophical theory is deontological?


What is the difference between rationalism and empiricism?


What is the statement 'God is Dead' talking about, and how is it relevant to the rise in Atheism?


We're here to help

contact us iconContact usWhatsapp logoMessage us on Whatsapptelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

© MyTutorWeb Ltd 2013–2024

Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy
Cookie Preferences