When should you use the imperfect and when the "passé composé" while narrating an episode in the past?

This is one of the trickiest aspects of learning how to use verbs in French, since English often lacks the clear distinction between the imperfect (in French expressed with verb forms with endings like '-ais'/'ait') and perfect ('avoir' plus the past participle, known as the passé composé). I have always imagined the difference between the two with the following analogy. Picture a stage. At the back is a colourful backdrop and some support cast miming. This is the information which should be conveyed in the imperfect: the scene is being set for the main drama later. If we were to describe what we see, this would be done in the imperfect: "Il faisait beau" ("The weather was nice"; "Des passants bavardaient" ("Some passersby were chatting"); "Le jardin était vert" ("The garden was green"). This should make clear the descriptive quality the imperfect often has, and also illustrates how these things are all ongoing and lack an obvious duration. Imagine now that the protagonist bursts onto the stage, screams, and drops dead. The perfect tense is used for precisely this, the main events, which will have a clear beginning and end. So: "Soudain, le voleur est entré" (Suddenly, the robber came in), "Il a crié, et puis est mort" (He shouted, and then died). If we put the two tenses together, the differences between the pair are clear: "Des passants bavardaient (imperfect: descriptive, ongoing, background info) quand le voleur est entré" (passé composé: sudden action, clear beginning and end). If you bear this distinction in mind, it will be a lot easier to pick the right tense when writing in the past in French.

Answered by Bennett S. French tutor

2130 Views

See similar French GCSE tutors

Related French GCSE answers

All answers ▸

When do you use 'a la' and when do you use 'au'? How do you know which one to use?


How do I know when to use which past tense in French when I'm translating/writing?


Why do some verbs take avoir and some take être in the perfect tense? How can I remember them?!


What is the difference between the passé composé and the imparfait tenses?


We're here to help

contact us iconContact usWhatsapp logoMessage us on Whatsapptelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo
Cookie Preferences