Your hospital has received an extra budget allowance this month, allowing either one life saving heart transplant operation for an eight year old child, or 100 hip replacements. Which do you choose and why?

An ethics question such as this is a common medical school interview question. It is important to appreciate there is no definite right answer, this is merely testing your ability to weigh up both sides of an ethical argument and come to an informed decision, explaining it as you work it through. 

Factors that may influence your decision might include the average age of the patients and therefore the amount of year's of use the treatment will get, whether the treatments can be postponed for the future, the social value of the patients, whether extension of life is more important than improved quality of life etc. Argue for and against on both points but try to be succient. It would be worth looking up terms such as utilitarianism and social value for future discussions. 

RH

Related Medical School Preparation Mentoring answers

All answers ▸

Why do you want to study medicine?


What do you need to do to get into medical school?


Actor station: You are a medical student breaking bad news to a patient


Describe the flow of an RBC from the right atrium through to the aorta. How might this change if there was a hole between the two atria? When/why might you want a hole between the two atria?