How to structure an answer to the question: 'Assess the view that Lenin’s rule between 1917 and l924 was merely a brutal dictatorship'.

First, we could ask if we both think that Lenin’s rule can simply be reduced to a ‘brutal dictatorship’. Do we not need to be more specific if we are going to properly understand the specificities of Russian history? I would start by suggesting that we draw a distinction between what Lenin says and what he does. Or what he wants to achieve and what he can achieve under the circumstances. This could be a good starting point for constructing an answer and lends itself well to examining some primary sources. For example, Lenin’s 26th October speech to the Soviet congress.

This question is lifted from one of the OCR 2017 sample papers for A level. The specification states that a thematic judgement is important if the candidate is to do well. Therefore, talking through some form of comparative analysis seems appropriate, what are the differences and similarities between Lenin, Stalin and the Tsars? Is Lenin an idealist like Nicolas ii? Unlike Stalin it is difficult to see Lenin subscribing to the principles of ‘Socialism in one Country’. From this we can establish what was general and particular about Lenin’s rule. This combined with a look at some sources can help the student come to a nuanced judgement on whether Lenin was merely a brutal dictator or a more sophisticated historical actor. This will hopefully leave enough space for the student to form their own opinion and advocate it convincingly.

Answered by Edward N. History tutor

2075 Views

See similar History A Level tutors

Related History A Level answers

All answers ▸

‘As soon as Richard Cromwell became Lord Protector, the restoration of the monarchy was inevitable’. Assess the validity of this view. [25 marks]


Was the potato famine of 1845 - 1852 a turning point for the Irish economy?


‘Henry’s treatment of his sons was a more important cause of the Great Rebellion than his baronial policy.’


‘Tudor rebellions before 1540 were primarily driven by economic factors.' Explain why you agree or disagree with this view


We're here to help

contact us iconContact usWhatsapp logoMessage us on Whatsapptelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

© MyTutorWeb Ltd 2013–2024

Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy
Cookie Preferences