Assess the significance of the role of the Papacy in bringing about change to the nature and purpose of crusading in the years 1095-1204.

During this period the papacy saw itself as the ultimate power in Christendom to which all men from peasants to emperors were subject. During the period of 1095-1204, popes such as Innocent III began to attempt to turn crusading theory into reality, drastically changing the nature of crusading. Crusades became a weapon with which the Papacy could defend itself militarily and politically. The difference between defence of Christendom and defence of the papal hierarchy became increasingly indistinct as the enemy became, not Muslim, but Christian. Both Greek orthodox and Latin Christians were targeted in examples ranging from Innocent III’s Crusades against Heretics such as the Cathars to Pope Martin IV’s crusade against Aragon. Aside from their motives the papacy instigated changes in the preaching, logistics and institutionalisation of crusading. By the time of Innocent III in the early 13th century it was highly professional, funded by taxes levelled on all the laity throughout Europe. One no longer had to actually go on the expedition and kill Saracens; he could pledge money, troops or ships and still his sins would be absolved. However for all the work the papacy did in changing the theory behind the crusade and the way in which it was called, it had little or no control over the crusading expeditions once they left Europe. It was relatively insignificant in changing or even dictating the aims of the crusaders once they actually reached the East. During the first crusade many of the most powerful nobles abandoned Urban’s crusade for wealth and land in the East, Baldwin headed straight to Edessa not Jerusalem and eventually settled down as king of the Christian community there.

Answered by Hugh W. History tutor

2097 Views

See similar History A Level tutors

Related History A Level answers

All answers ▸

‘Richard Nixon proved himself to be a master of statesmanship in foreign affairs’ Assess the validity of this view.


'Edmond is clearly a villain, but he is also by far the most attractive character we meet.' Discuss.


Was the potato famine of 1845 - 1852 a turning point for the Irish economy?


‘Without the Falklands War, Margaret Thatcher would have lost the 1983 General Election.’ Assess the validity of this view.


We're here to help

contact us iconContact usWhatsapp logoMessage us on Whatsapptelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo
Cookie Preferences