When assessing source value, how do I balance contextual information with source relevance and general analysis?

Exam questions will often ask you to assess the usefulness of a source(s) to a historian or to consider how convincing or relevant certain sources are. Whilst it is important to demonstrate your source analysis skills, it is also important to show contextual awareness and to demonstrate your own knowledge of the topic. Before analysing the source, you can include any relevant background information you might have surrounding the time it was produced or motivation behind its production, provided this is not too long and doesn’t become the essence of your answer. It is important to keep the question you are being asked in mind the entire time you are writing your response, and to only include contextual information which is relevant to your answer. For example, if you are being asked what makes industry data during one of Stalin’s Five-Year-Plans relevant to a historian of the period, acknowledging its importance in terms of propaganda, the life of workers’ and Russia’s economic development is appropriate, however it is not necessary to include detailed information on the plans or an in-depth explanation of why these results were achieved. General analysis should always include basic observations such as source type, who produced it, when/where and how it was produced etc. However, it is also important to acknowledge why these observations are relevant, which is where your contextual knowledge should come in. After practicing these types of questions for a while, combining and balancing general analysis with contextual information should come naturally. 

GB
Answered by Georgina B. History tutor

2483 Views

See similar History A Level tutors

Related History A Level answers

All answers ▸

How do I structure an essay in an exam?


How do I structure a 25-mark essay question, such as '‘Democracy in Britain in 1885 was little different from that in 1846.’ Assess the validity of this view.'


What are the causes of the French Revolution?


How do I know what examples to use in a depth essay?


We're here to help

contact us iconContact ustelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

MyTutor is part of the IXL family of brands:

© 2025 by IXL Learning