What if the author didn't 'mean' all the things we're analysing?

Although authorial intention can illuminate a reading of a certain text, it is in many ways irrelevant. The author will have been impacted by things in his/her lifetime that they may not have been aware of , and they may even be part of a broader movement that is yet to be established. As such, there are myriad ways to read any text.In his famous essay, 'The Death of the Author', Roland Barthes argues that as language is only given reading by the reader. In essence, he believes that a word alone is meaningless unless there is a reader there to process the letters and attach a meaning to it. If this is true, then 'meaning' in a text comes from a reader, not an author. By using Barthes' argument, we can certainly make a case that every possible reading we can conceive when reading a text has a certain level of validity.

JH

Related English Literature A Level answers

All answers ▸

Mary Shelley describes 'Frankenstein' as her "hideous progeny". To what extent does Frankenstein's "Creature" represent the true monstrosity of the novel?


“Desire dazzles and destroys.” Compare the presentation of the destructive power of desire in one poetry and one drama text you have studied.


To what extent could it be argued that the aesthetic representation of the women in Keats’ ‘Lamia’ and Swift’s ‘The Lady’s Dressing Room’ is used in order to vilify them?


Compare and contrast...