How accurate is it to say that the Pilgrimage of Grace of 1536 was a reaction to Henry VIII's dissolution of the monasteries?

Intro- Make your main argument (e.g. Although the dissolution of the monasteries was a key factor in causing the pilgrimage of grace, it could be seen as more of a spark which exacerbated underlying causes and griefs such as general discontent and hunger as a result of a series of failed harvests and previous religious changes that had taken place or even the role that the nobility played due to their discontent at the influence that Thomas Cromwell had over the king at court.)Paragraphs- Introduce each of your arguments into the essay giving each one a paragraph to develop with an explanation and a couple of examples to make the argument more convincing (e.g. Though the timing of the rebellion might suggest that it was a direct reaction to the dissolution of the monasteries, one ought to consider the role that the nobility played. For they in essence led the rebellion and the list of grievances which were presented to the Duke of Norfolk, who was sent to meet them and organise a truce, included several concerning court factionism and grievances they had about Thomas Cromwell misleading the King in government matters.) Make sure to always link your argument back to the question, answer it directly and ensure you support your thesis from the introduction.Conclusion- Summarise they key arguments made in your essay coming to a balanced conclusion answering the question directly. (It should match the overall thesis you introduced at the start of the essay) (e.g. In conclusion, considering the fact that there were several underlying causes for the vast rebellion in 1536, including court factionism, general discontent at the hunger caused by a series of failed harvests and anger at previously implemented religious changes, it is fair to say that the Pilgrimage of Grace was not directly a reaction to the Dissolution of the Monasteries. Instead it can be argued that the Dissolution of the Monasteries acted as a spark which exacerbated the underlying conditions and grievances without which the Pilgrimage of Grace wouldn't have taken hold so extensively.)

Answered by History tutor

3890 Views

See similar History A Level tutors

Related History A Level answers

All answers ▸

Asses the view that political factors best explain the American withdrawal from Vietnam.


How do I write about the New Deal and it's effectiveness?


How far do you agree that granting the vote to women was the most important political development in Wales and England in the period 1880-1951?


How successful were Elizabeth I and her ministers in managing Parliament?


We're here to help

contact us iconContact ustelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

MyTutor is part of the IXL family of brands:

© 2026 by IXL Learning