What is an indirect question? How do I identify it?

An indirect question is a question which has been previously asked and is now being reported. An example of this in english is: The teacher asked whether the students had done their homework. The original question in this circumstance would be: Have the students done their homework / Have you (the students) done your homework?The indirect question in english can be identified the same way as it is identified in the latin; there will be a verb of knowing/asking followed by a question word (whether/why/what/how etc). Therefore in latin there will be a verb of knowing/asking (such as rogo/quaero/scio) and then a question word (cur/quid/num) - the only difference is then it is followed by a subjunctive verb. The tense of the subjunctive is usually the same as english i.e if the secondary erb in the sentence (the subjunctive) is in the imperfect subjunctive it is translated as a simple past tense; if the pluperfect subjunctive is used, the translated would be something like "the students were asked whether they HAD done the homework. Here are a few worked examples:DIC  MIHI  QUIS  IN  SENATU  HODIE  LOQUERETUR. - here we can see question word 'quis' followed by the imperfect subjunctive --> translation = Tell me WHO WAS speaking in the Senate today.PATER  FILIAM  ROGAVIT  QUID  IN  FORO  EMISSET - here 'quid' is followed by the pluperfect subjunctive which causes the translation to include HAD --> translation = The father asked his daughter WHAT she HAD bought in the forum. NESCIMUS  QUANDO  AMICI  ADVENTURI  SINT. - 'quando' in this sentence is followed by a FUTURE subjunctive --> translation = We don't know WHEN our friends WILL arrive.CIVES  COGNOSCERE VOLEBANT  NUM  EXERCITUS  IN PROELIO  VICISSET. - 'num' in this example is used when the direct question may have included -ne/nonne/num and should just be translated as whether (representing an open question) --> translation = The citizens wanted to know IF/WHETHER their army HAD won the battle.

Answered by Alicia E. Latin tutor

7256 Views

See similar Latin GCSE tutors

Related Latin GCSE answers

All answers ▸

How should I approach translating a complex sentence?


What do different cases used in temporal clauses mean?


Decline the 5th Declension Noun 'spes'


What is the main difference between Latin and English?


We're here to help

contact us iconContact usWhatsapp logoMessage us on Whatsapptelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

© MyTutorWeb Ltd 2013–2024

Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy
Cookie Preferences