Explain why the Catholic Church was criticised in the early sixteenth century.

I would open my teaching of how to answer with this question by inviting the students to consider the structure of the early 16th Century Catholic Church and Papacy, based on the division of power and the placement of religious authority. From this we would be able to draw conclusions as to the failings of the Church in the period, such as nepotism, corruption, the purchase of office, clerical absence and scriptural ignorance. In looking at the factual reality of the Church, we could develop a point based on the incongruence between the Pope as a religious and spiritual leader, and as the temporal Prince of the Papal States, a crown that frequently became involved in geopolitical conflict and warfare- such as in the Italian Wars in the immediate run-up to the period described in the question. We would then return to the initial notion of the basic structure of the Roman Catholic church- unified under a single individual and geographic location- and explore how this caused conflicts with nascent feelings of nationhood, using the very philosophy of Martin Luther and many of his supporters in the Holy Roman Empire in the context of their view of the Papacy as an invasive, perfidious influence on 'Germany'. We would make this argument with reference to relevant primary source material, such as Luther's own writings or the view offered by Ulrich von Hutten's work, understanding the semantic significance of 'Germany' as a new concept.

EJ
Answered by Elliot J. History tutor

4420 Views

See similar History A Level tutors

Related History A Level answers

All answers ▸

Which was more important in Napoleon's initial acquisition of political power, his campaigns in Europe or his suppression of royalist revolts?


How do I analyse a historical source?


To what extent were economic realities the most important factor in pushing both sides towards detente by 1972?


To what extent is it reasonable to suggest that the expansion of the Royal Navy in the years 1763-1914 was the result of political imperatives?


We're here to help

contact us iconContact ustelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

MyTutor is part of the IXL family of brands:

© 2026 by IXL Learning